TWO BOOKS : Why Religion?, AND, The Alphabet Versus The Goddess

Admit it. ¬†You’re a believer. ¬†You believe in something, many things. ¬†Anyone who has ever taken Philosophy 101 has heard this question: why is there something rather than nothing?¬†(Nothing¬†is what the rocks dream of, wrote Aristotle.) ¬†You¬†“believe” but the varieties of belief are vast. ¬†Perhaps you believe in a god of wrath who, like santa claus, knows naughty from nice ; ¬†or in¬†ha satan¬†(Hebrew for¬†the accuser:¬†AKA satan, the boogey man) ; ¬†or in material reductionism (a determinism which denies free will, arguing that atomic force-fields comprise reality, denying that you have any choice) ; ¬†or in a Messiah (ever-present, or yet to come, and/or in an attendant Holy Ghost) ; ¬†or in The Church of Medicine (no heretics or free-thinkers allowed) ; ¬†or naturopathy ; ¬†or in sex-drugs-and rock’n’roll ; ¬†or simply in¬†gardening your beliefs.¬† ¬†Interpretation is¬†everything. ¬†And culture shapes our beliefs. ¬†So, on to the two books . . .¬†

I’ve just finished reading both books depicted above, back to back. ¬† What a fabulous experience! ¬†I read the Alphabet book first, but at 450 pages, I suggest you start with¬†Why Religion?, as it’s faster paced, and gripping. ¬†I’ve enjoyed several books by Elaine Pagels, and am stunned by the candor of her storytelling here. ¬†It’s autobiographical ‚ÄĒ painfully so. ¬†She relates the loss of her first child, age 6, followed by the death of her husband, a prominent physicist, a year later while on a group hike, shortly after they had adopted two infants. ¬†(I’ll put her book alongside a classic by CS Lewis, titled¬†A Grief Observed.) ¬†While the Pagels book could be prickly for someone recovering from loss of a loved one, her telling contains blessings, and surprises. ¬†(Read it before gifting it.) ¬†It contains much wisdom about consoling the bereaved. ¬†She deals with anger, rage, superstition, alcoholism, depression, theology, and much more.

Next, The Alphabet Versus the Goddess, was written by a nuerosurgeon who was also a competent scholar with interests in history, anthropology, language, and gender-issues. ¬†He, too, is a great storyteller ‚ÄĒ and his book argues compellingly that the world became a crueler place due to the invention of reading and writing, when matriarchy was displaced by patriarchy (and by its male hunting-parties and armies). ¬†Momma! ‚Äďthis book is an education. And it’s in the collection at Merida English Library, with a Dewey number of 302.22.

The Pagels book can also be found there, as I have donated my copy to the collection.



2 thoughts on “TWO BOOKS : Why Religion?, AND, The Alphabet Versus The Goddess

  1. Another powerful story about loss and recovery, linked below, fits well with the Pagels book. The story is about an athlete who had a scholarship, but was so seriously injured in his sport that he could no longer hold the scholarship. His coach stood by him, and insisted the school find other studies.

    The coach became a co-founder of Nike footwear, and the athlete became their top designer. Here (first) if you have Netflix, or if not, a shorter interview at Youtube: .

    If you don’t have Netflix, you can catch the sense of the story with this interview, (which isn’t nearly as good) :

  2. Excerpt from a fine essay:

    “Everyone has a religion. It is, in fact, impossible not to have a religion if you are a human being. It‚Äôs in our genes and has expressed itself in every culture, in every age, including our own secularized husk of a society.

    “By religion, I mean something quite specific: a practice not a theory; a way of life that gives meaning, a meaning that cannot really be defended without recourse to some transcendent value, undying ‚ÄúTruth‚ÄĚ or God (or gods).

Comments are closed.